Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood faces scrutiny over changes to the rules for legal migrants, according to a BBC Politics analysis by Chris Mason. The report says her plan, called "a fairer pathway to settlement," would lengthen the baseline qualifying period for indefinite leave to remain for some lower-paid migrants with non-working dependants from five years to 15 years.

Mahmood said in November that her plan aimed to address net migration of 2.6 million people between 2021 and 2024. She argued that this group would present "significant fiscal costs to the UK." Under the current rules, she said, these migrants would usually qualify for benefits and council housing five years after arrival, which would begin in 2027.

The report says about 200,000 people responded to the consultation, including 140,000 visa holders. A Whitehall source described the exercise to the BBC as "a colossal exercise and a genuine one."

Angela Rayner, now Housing Secretary, criticised the ideas in March. She called them "un-British" and said they involved "moving the goalposts." The report says around 100 Labour colleagues were unhappy with the plans. It also says parts of the original proposal are now being revised.

The report cites Home Office visa figures showing 727,487 visa entries from July 2025 to June 2026, excluding visitors and transit passengers. That figure was down 15% on the previous year. Study visas made up 53% of entries, and people from China and India accounted for nearly half of study visas.

Mahmood put the lifetime cost to taxpayers at £10bn, based on Migration Advisory Committee findings. The Institute for Public Policy Research disputes that figure, arguing the original plans would delay settlement for care workers rather than prevent it, and that the £10bn estimate includes broader long-run costs.