Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood has scaled back two parts of her immigration settlement plans after pressure from Labour MPs. Social care workers who arrived before May 2025 and earn at least £25,000 a year will now qualify for settlement after five years, rather than the 15 years the original plans would have required.
The retrospective element of the plans has not changed. People who came to the UK expecting settlement after five years may now have to wait longer. Housing Secretary Angela Rayner had described that approach as "un-British" and said the government should not be shifting "the goalposts."
Most Labour MPs stopped short of open revolt when Mahmood made a statement in the House of Commons. Rachael Maskell was the strongest critic, objecting to the retrospective element. John McDonnell and Diane Abbott were critical without being scathing.
Mahmood's opposite number, Conservative shadow home secretary Chris Philp, accused her of a significant U-turn. He pointed to her earlier claim that allowing care workers to reach settlement more quickly could cost the UK £10bn. Mahmood told the BBC she would not say what financial burden the change would create. She also declined to confirm whether Prime Minister Andy Burnham had directly asked her to water down the plans.
According to the report, the changes will delay the settlement path for around 500,000 people, compared with around 800,000 under the original plans.